Any Monmouth County home valuation starts with the county number and then has to leave it behind. A home here sold for a median of $757,452 over the three months ending October 2026, up 3.1% from the same period a year earlier, according to Redfin’s Monmouth County housing market page. Homes went under contract in a median of 24 days, five days faster than last year, and Redfin counted 727 homes sold in October against 688 a year earlier.
That figure describes the county. It does not describe your street, and Monmouth is not one market. What your specific house brings depends on things no county median can see.
Who do I contact for a Monmouth County home valuation?
Me. I am Shea Merritt, a licensed New Jersey Realtor® with eXp Realty, working as Shea Merritt Real Estate. Send me the address of the house and I will pull the comparable sales on that specific property and send back a written Monmouth County home valuation, usually the same day. My phone is 908-331-6006.
I cover Monmouth County, including Manalapan, Marlboro, Matawan, Aberdeen, Freehold and Keyport, and that list is not a limit.
What a Monmouth County home valuation gets you, and when
Not an instant number. A figure I can show my work on.
I look at what has actually sold near you over recent months, walk the house where I can, and account for the things a model cannot: condition, updates, layout, what the property backs onto, how it shows on a Sunday afternoon.
Then you get three things. What I think it brings today. What it would bring with a specific list of work done first. And whether that work is worth paying for, because a good deal of it is not.
If the honest answer is that this is a poor moment for you to sell, I will say so. I would rather be the agent you call in two years than the one who talked you into a listing that sat.
Send me the address
Send me the address and roughly when you are thinking about moving. I will reply personally, and there is nothing automated waiting on the other end of it.
Why your assessment is a poor guide to value
This is where Monmouth differs sharply from the county next door, and it catches people who compare notes with relatives.
New Jersey publishes a Director’s Ratio for every municipality each year. It is the share of true market value that town’s assessments are running at. The 2026 table for Monmouth County, certified on May 22, 2026, puts most of the county at or above full value.
| Municipality | 2026 Director’s Ratio |
| Aberdeen Township | 108.43% |
| Keyport Borough | 105.30% |
| Freehold Township | 105.08% |
| Matawan Borough | 104.63% |
| Freehold Borough | 101.38% |
| Manalapan Township | 100.19% |
| Marlboro Township | 61.58% |
Two things follow. In most of the county, an assessment sitting above your likely sale price is normal, and it does not mean the house is worth more than you think. It means the town’s assessments have drifted past market. And Marlboro is the outlier inside its own county at 61.58%, so a Marlboro assessment understates market value by a wide margin while a Matawan one overstates it.
That matters more than it sounds, because Middlesex County runs the other way entirely. On the same 2026 tables, Old Bridge sits at 28.33% and East Brunswick at 17.44%. Anyone comparing their number with family across the county line is comparing two completely different scales. Those figures come from the county equalization tables published by the New Jersey Division of Taxation.
What an algorithm does instead
An automated valuation finds recent sales near you and adjusts for square footage, bedrooms and lot size. In a subdivision where every house is a variation on four floor plans and something sells every month, that works reasonably well.
Monmouth County is mostly not that. Building eras, lot sizes and conditions change from street to street and sometimes within a single street. Two houses with an identical stat line can finish tens of thousands of dollars apart.
The model cannot see a roof replaced three years ago, a kitchen untouched since the house was built, or a finished basement nobody pulled a permit for. It cannot see that the comparable it just applied to you was a gut renovation, or an estate sale that went out the door as-is. It is averaging houses nobody has looked at. That is the gap a Monmouth County home valuation done by a person is meant to close.
One boundary worth stating plainly
I am a real estate agent, so what I can tell you is what the market will pay. What your specific assessment ought to be is a conversation for your town’s assessor, and a formal tax appeal is a legal filing worth discussing with a New Jersey tax appeal attorney.