What Is My Home Worth?
If you are asking what is my home worth, you can have a number in about four seconds. A dozen websites will hand you one. The real question is what that number was built from, and whether a buyer would ever write it on a contract.
There are two answers to it. There is the figure an algorithm produces from public records, and there is the figure the market will actually pay. On a given house those can sit a long way apart, and the reasons are not mysterious once you look at them.
What you get, and when
Not an instant number. A figure I can show my work on.
I look at what has actually sold near you over recent months, walk the house where I can, and account for the things a model cannot: condition, updates, layout, what the property backs onto, how it shows on a Sunday afternoon.
Then you get three things. What I think it brings today. What it would bring with a specific list of work done first. And whether that work is worth paying for, because a good deal of it is not.
If the honest answer is that this is a poor moment for you to sell, I will say so. I would rather be the agent you call in two years than the one who talked you into a listing that sat.
Send me the address
Send me the address and roughly when you are thinking about moving. I will reply personally, usually the same day, and there is nothing automated waiting on the other end of it.
What is my home worth according to an algorithm?
An automated valuation finds recent sales near you and adjusts for square footage, bedrooms and lot size. In a subdivision where every house is a variation on four floor plans and something sells every month, that works reasonably well.
Most of Central New Jersey is not that. Monmouth, Middlesex and Ocean counties are a patchwork of building eras, lot sizes and conditions, frequently on the same street. Two houses with an identical stat line can finish tens of thousands of dollars apart.
The model cannot see a roof replaced three years ago, a kitchen untouched since the house was built, or a finished basement nobody pulled a permit for. It cannot see that the comparable it just applied to you was a gut renovation, or an estate sale that went out the door as-is. It is averaging houses nobody has looked at.
Your assessment is not your market value
This one costs people real money, because assessments are public and easy to look up.
New Jersey towns assess property at whatever fraction of true market value they landed on the last time they revalued, and then drift from there. The state publishes the size of that gap every year as an equalization ratio. The numbers are nowhere near each other.
Take the 2026 table for Middlesex County, certified in April. Woodbridge comes in at 17.28% and Carteret at 112.87%. Old Bridge is 28.33%, East Brunswick 17.44%. Those are all municipalities in the same county.
So one town’s assessments are running at roughly a sixth of market value while another’s are running above it. Compare your assessment to a relative’s in the next town and you learn nothing. When an online tool leans on assessment data without correcting for the ratio, it inherits that distortion and passes it to you as a price. That is why the assessment is the wrong starting point for anyone asking what is my home worth.
When a town does revalue, the whole gap closes at once and every assessment in town changes at the same time. Old Bridge is going through exactly that, and what it does to a homeowner’s number is worth understanding before a notice lands.
These counties do not move together
Monmouth, Middlesex and Ocean get discussed as one market. They are not one market, and the towns inside them are not either.
Pace is where it shows up hardest. A house that looks stalled in one county is running perfectly on schedule in another, which matters a great deal when you are watching your own listing and wondering whether something has gone wrong. The honest answer usually depends on which clock you should have been reading.
I keep current figures on the pages where they belong rather than here, because they move every month. There are closer versions of this page for Old Bridge and for Monmouth County.
One boundary worth stating plainly
I am a real estate agent, so what I can tell you is what the market will pay. What your specific assessment ought to be is a conversation for your town’s assessor, and a formal tax appeal is a legal filing worth discussing with a New Jersey tax appeal attorney.