Skip to main content

For as long as most people have been buying houses, your mortgage credit score was a fact about you. One number, pulled more or less the same way by every lender, and whatever it said, it said.

That stopped being true in September. Two lenders can now pull two different numbers on the same borrower in the same week, and both are legitimate. If you are shopping for a pre-approval in New Jersey right now, that changes how you should go about it.

What actually changed with the mortgage credit score

The Federal Housing Finance Agency oversees Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, which between them stand behind most conventional loans in this country. In July 2025 it set an interim policy letting lenders use either Classic FICO or VantageScore 4.0.

The practical opening came later. FHFA’s own credit score page, updated October 2, 2026, records that FHFA opened VantageScore 4.0 to all approved lenders on September 9, 2026, and dropped the prior written approval requirement. On September 30 the agency aligned upfront fees so the two models now cost the same.

FHFA has also approved a third model, FICO 10T, though lenders cannot yet deliver loans on it. FHFA expects to retire Classic FICO eventually. It states plainly that it has announced no retirement date.

So the current situation is a real choice. A lender may use Classic FICO or VantageScore 4.0, loan by loan. The one firm rule: whichever model they pick, they must use it for every borrower on that loan.

Two lenders, two numbers

This is the part that matters when you are holding three pre-approval letters and trying to work out why they do not agree.

They may not be reading the same mortgage credit score. One lender ran Classic FICO and another ran VantageScore 4.0. The two models weigh a credit file differently. A gap between letters is no longer proof that somebody made a mistake, or that one lender is being generous with you.

It also means a number you were quoted elsewhere is not portable. If a lender tells you where you stand, that is where you stand with that lender, under the model that lender ran.

Who the change should help

Worth being careful here. Most of the commentary on this comes from the company whose model just won approval.

VantageScore says its 4.0 model uses alternative data, including rent, utility and telecommunications payments. It also says the model drops two requirements older ones imposed. One was recent credit activity. The other was a credit file older than six months. It estimates five million Americans stand to benefit.

Those are VantageScore’s own figures and its own wording. I have not seen an independent count that confirms them.

What seems fair to say is the direction rather than the size. A model that can score a thinner file is likely to help somebody who pays rent on time and carries little other credit. That is a real population around here. It is part of why your rent payment history is worth more than it used to be.

It does not follow that your own mortgage credit score goes up. Say you have a long, clean, conventional credit file. There is no particular reason to expect a new model to treat it better. It might go the other way.

Why a mortgage credit score matters more in a competitive market

Here is the local piece.

In September, 46.4% of Middlesex County sales closed above asking. When that many houses are drawing competition, sellers are not only reading the price on an offer. They are reading how likely it is to actually close.

A pre-approval that comes apart costs a seller weeks. It also puts the listing back on the market carrying a stigma it did not earn. So the strength of your financing is part of what you are offering. Anything that makes your approval look unsettled is a cost you pay here. That is why the highest offer is not automatically the best one from where the seller sits.

None of that is cause for alarm. It is a reason to have your financing settled before you start looking at houses rather than after you have found one.

What I would do about it

One boundary first. I am a real estate agent, not a lender, so this is about how to shop rather than which loan to take. Which model suits your file, and what it does to your rate, are questions for a loan officer.

Ask which model they ran. “Classic FICO or VantageScore 4.0?” is a reasonable question now, and a lender who cannot answer it quickly has told you something useful.

Compare letters on the same basis. If two pre-approvals disagree, ask whether both lenders used the same model before you decide one is better.

Get fully underwritten rather than pre-qualified. In a market where nearly half of sales clear asking, that difference is worth real money when a seller is choosing between offers.

And do not go shopping for the model that flatters you. A number that only exists at one lender is not much use if that lender is not the one you want to close with.

If you are starting to look in Monmouth, Middlesex or Ocean County, get the financing settled before you fall in love with something. Tell me where you are in the process and I will point you at the right first step.

Shea Merritt

Shea Merritt is a licensed New Jersey real estate agent with eXp Realty, working with buyers and sellers across Middlesex, Monmouth, and Ocean counties. He grew up in Old Bridge. He writes here about the arithmetic behind a move: what a house would actually bring today, what the tax line does to a monthly payment, and how to compare offers on their terms rather than on the top number. If you are weighing a sale or a purchase, send him the address and he will run the numbers on it.